← A Level Economics Revision · All Negative consumption externality questions · Home

A-Level Economics · Negative consumption externality diagram question

Smoking harms bystanders: MSB sits BELOW MPB. Which point is the FREE-MARKET outcome?

▶ Try it in the game first

The diagram

The answer

Point E. Smokers weigh only their PRIVATE benefit: MPB crosses S at point E, quantity 5 — too much for society. Consumers act on MPB, ignoring the harm to others, so the market settles where MPB crosses S: point E — an OVERconsumption.

Test yourself properly

This is one of 5 questions on the negative consumption externality diagram — every corner lettered, every wrong answer diagnosed.

▶ Play the negative consumption externality game All questions & answers

George Chantry
Professional A-Level Economics tutor · Oxford PPE First, 3 prizes in economics · 7,000+ hours one-to-one